Sanibel Island Condos with last minute specials and flexible scheduling - Call 800-336-6722

Not a Keeper!

This shell was returned to the sea. As you can see, this is a fortunate release for this big guy, and what a beauty he is! Luckily for him, he is very much alive and needs to return to his home in the Gulf!

For those of you that might not be familiar with this practice, it is a law that no live shells on Sanibel are allowed to be taken from the beach.

In fact, Kathleen Hoover, from the Bailey-Mathews Shell Museum writes that they have received a number of complaints from volunteers and visitors regarding collection of live shells they have witnessed. In response to this information an article was prepared for the local island newspapers. We are hoping that by providing information about how to determine if the shell is living and sharing what can be learned by observing mollusks in their environment, we will at least deter those individuals collecting due to a lack of information/understanding. A copy of the article follows.

Wanted . . . . Dead Not Alive
By Kathleen E. Hoover

Sanibel is often referred to as the shelling capital of North America. Strolling the beaches
and shallow water surrounding Sanibel and Captiva over 300 species of shells can be
discovered. These treasures are what lure many island visitors.

To protect this important economic and biological asset, in the late 1980s, the city of
Sanibel petitioned the Florida Marine Fisheries Commission (MFC) to restrict live-
shelling and the MFC passed a special Sanibel Shelling Rule restricting live collection
to two specimens of any one species per day per person. In addition, non-residents were
required to purchase a State saltwater products fishing license. This rule remained in
effect for six years, but it was difficult to enforce.

In 1994 the city asked MFC to establish a complete ban on live-shelling for Sanibel
beaches to one-half mile from shore. This rule prohibits the harvest and possession of
live shellfish as well as sand dollars, sea stars and sea urchins. Also, all shelling was
prohibited within the waters of the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge. A first
offense could result in a fine of $500 and up to 60 days in jail. This went into effect on
January 1, 1995. In January of 2002, Lee County proposed a county-wide ban on the
collection of all live shells. This ban took effect March 1, 2002. The ban remains in
effect and is strictly enforced.

The first question that generally follows awareness of the live-shelling ban is, “how
can I tell if the shell is alive or dead?” The sniff test is where to begin. Hold the shell
carefully in your hand and take a whiff, if you experience a rather obnoxious odor, it
is highly likely that the mollusk responsible for building the shell is no longer living.
Another method involves placing the specimen gently at the water’s edge or in a tidal
pool and watch for any movement. If the specimen is a gastropod (one piece whorled
shell) check to see if there is an operculum or trap door and if there is any movement.

There are many joys associated with shelling beyond “the hunt” for a junonia, lions paw,
or even better, a brand new species. One of them is observing live mollusks in their
natural habitat and learning more about what form of locomotion they employ, what they
eat, which species they fall prey to, how they reproduce, and whether they leave “trails”
that help the inquisitive nature enthusiast find and identify them.

There are some “rules of the road” if you have an interest in observing live shells in their
natural environment. Always put the shell back where you found it by gently placing it
on the sea floor. Gastropods should be placed with the aperture or opening down. Do
not throw shells back into the sea as this will cause injury and probable death. If objects
in the environment like rocks, or branches are moved during observation, be sure to put
the objects back where you found them.

Visit The Bailey-Matthews Shell Museum to learn more about the exciting world of
mollusks.

3 Responses to “Not a Keeper!”

  1. sue austin Says:

    I was saddened and annoyed by many things I observed on the beach this year. There was more litter, more beach equipment left overnight, etc. I talked to several people on the beach who had no clue about live shells/dead shells or turtle nests. I wish there were signs on every path to the beach and every refridgerator door on Sanibel! I want to think it is ignorance, not apathy.

    Even so, Sanibel is the greatest!

  2. karen wade Says:

    I completely agree with Sue Austin’s post and I think it would be fantastic if Ocean’s Reach could include a full-page in the big white envelope of handouts about NOT taking live shells from the water. I observed one blissfully ignorant family group putting live shells in a plastic bag of sea water and hanging the bag on a beach chair for hours in the hot sun thus killing the mollusks inside. I also agree that posting signs on the pathways to the beach would catch and educate a few more people. It never ceases to amaze me how many people have absolutely no clue. Many are more than willing to do the right thing for nature once they know what it is. But you have to put the information where they will see it or they won’t go looking for it. So the more places it’s posted the greater the uptake.

  3. dru Says:

    Thank you to Sue and Karen for those good ideas and for keeping us straight and legal.
    Our team will decide the best course of action for educating our guests about this important issue. We are grateful for your caring and oversight!!

Sanibel Island Map/directions  |  Trip Cancellation Insurance  |  Valued Guest Survey  |  More Photos...  |  Ocean's Reach Apartment - Available
Condos for Sale  |  Subscribe to e news "Beach Wrap" mail list  |  Sanibel Blog  |  Contact Us
site map  |  print this page  |  send this page to a friend  |  bookmark this page